Roasting Your Own Tomatoes

The key to good roasted tomatoes is to use fresh tomatoes that still have that lovely tomato aroma! Heirlooms are particularly amazing if you can get your hands on any!

How to Roast Tomatoes

  • Servings: Varies
  • Print

1-2 quarts of fresh in-season tomatoes, washed and cut in half (I love a nice variety)
1/4 cup olive oil
1/2 tsp. or two finger pinch of coarse kosher salt
1/4 tsp. or 6-7 grinds of fresh ground black pepper
Pinch of dried red chili peppers (optional)
2 T Italian seasoning (or a mix of basil, oregano and thyme)
2-3 cloves garlic, minced
1-2 T aged balsamic vinegar

Mix all ingredients together in a bowl.

Roasting Methods:
Line a large baking sheet with parchment paper. Choose a baking time that works best for you. The longer they bake, the more intense the flavor will be.

300°F for 1 – 2 hours
375°F for 45 minutes – 1 hour
450°F for 25-30 minutes

To save the roasted tomatoes for later use, place them in a jar and cover with a 1/3″ of olive oil. Store in fridge for up to one week or put them in a freezer-safe container with no more than 1/4” head space (for air) and freeze.

Cherry tomatoes like Sun Golds are the absolute best for pure sweet tomato flavor!

4 responses to “Roasting Your Own Tomatoes”

  1. […] bread loaf (about 7 inches in diameter and 3 inches high)1/2 cup Roasted Tomatoes (store bought or roast your own)1/2 Basil Pesto (store bought or make your own)1/3 lb. ham slices of your choice1/3 lb. turkey […]

  2. […] Marzano)1/4 cup good quality tomato paste(1) 12 oz. jar of good quality tomato sauce**Or see how to roast your own tomatoes on this site.Simmer for 15-20 minutes, stirring occasionally.  Turn off burner, put the top on and […]

  3. […] flavor.  I also add about 8 oz. of some tomatoes I keep in the freezer from last summer (See Roasting Your Own Tomatoes on this site).  In lieu of that. however, you can also add a couple T. of tomato paste).  A […]

  4. […] Bakery has one that is terrific)1-1/2 lb. of tri-tip steakCaramelized Shallots (see below)Roasted TomatoesRoasted Garlic MayoArugulaGorgonzolaRed Wine Marinade (see below)Red Wine VinaigretteRed Wine […]

Leave a reply to Italian Muffeleta – Beloved Recipe Box Cancel reply

Hi, I’m Isabel!

Welcome to Beloved Recipe Box!

When a carefully made feast is prepared, we tend to linger. And these days, sitting down together allows us to dig deeper into how we can be more fully present for the planet and each other in these crazy times.

This group of recipes are tried and true. As recipe requests have increased over the years (and my original recipe cards became dog-eared and food stained), it was clear it was time to create a larger recipe box for them here.

You won’t find any ads on these recipe cards. Just bring a smile, feel welcome and enjoy!!